Avoid the “Best Islands” in San Blas (Insider Guide)

The “Best Island” Myth. You’re planning your dream trip. You just typed “best islands in San Blas” into Google. You found a “Top 10” list, and you’ve already added “Isla Perro” (Dog Island) and the “Piscina Natural” (Natural Pool) to your itinerary.

As a captain who has sailed these 365 islands for over a decade, I am here to tell you the most important secret of your trip: You should probably avoid all of them.

This is the San Blas paradox: the most famous islands are the least magical. They are the “tourist traps.”

The “best” island in San Blas isn’t a name. It’s the one you have all to yourself. This is the insider’s guide to finding that island.

The “Tourist Trap” Circuit: What You’re Really Getting

Why are islands like Isla Perro so “famous”?

The answer is simple: they are part of the “San Blas Day Trip Circuit.” They are the only islands that the high-volume, 1-day tours from Panama City can reach.

From 10 AM to 3 PM, these “famous” islands are loud, crowded, and completely inauthentic. They are a “theme park,” not a paradise.

• The Reality of “Isla Perro” (dog islands): Yes, it has a cool shipwreck to snorkel. But by 11 AM, it will be swarmed with 100+ people from 10+ different lanchas, all snorkeling in the same 50-square-foot area.
• The Reality of the “Piscina Natural” (natural pool): This beautiful sandbar is a “boat parking lot.” It’s filled with dozens of day-trip boats, often blaring competing music.

This is not the San Blas you are dreaming of. This is a 4-hour, rushed, high-stress experience. (Read our full Honest Review of the San Blas Day Trip here).

The Real “Best Islands”: A Captain’s Private Map

The true, mind-blowing, “paradise found” islands have no names. They are not on any “Top 10” list. They are the 300+ other islands that no day-trip boat can reach.

When a Nomad Sailors guest asks me to “see the best,” here is where we really go.

The Crown Jewel: The Holandeses Cays

This is it. This is the postcard. The Holandeses Cays are a remote, outer chain of islands, a 3-4 hour sail from the crowded “Carti” area.

• Why it’s the “Best”: It’s too far for day-trippers. The water is clearer, the reefs are 100% pristine, and the islands are completely uninhabited.
• The Nomad Sailors Experience: We don’t just “visit.” We anchor. We will be the only boat in a turquoise-blue bay. You will take the paddleboard and be the only human on a one-mile stretch of perfect white sand. This is the “best island.”

The Cultural Heart: The Coco Banderos Cays

This is a stunningly beautiful, protected group of islands that offers the perfect mix of privacy and culture.

• Why it’s the “Best”: It’s perfectly protected from the open-ocean swell, creating a massive, calm “swimming pool.”
• The Nomad Sailors Experience: We’ll anchor here for the night. A Guna fisherman, a friend of our captain, will pull up in his ulu (canoe) with a lobster he caught for your private chef. You’ll eat that lobster for dinner, under the stars, in total silence. You cannot get this experience from a “Top 10” list.

The “Key” to Paradise: Why You Need a Private Charter

So, how do you get to the real “best islands”?

This is the most important part: You cannot get there on a day trip.

Why? Because those packages run on a fixed, rigid itinerary. They have to go to the “famous” islands, because that’s what they sold.

The only way to unlock the true, private, 300+ islands of San Blas is on a private luxury charter.

• Freedom: At Nomad Sailors there is no fixed itinerary.
• Flexibility: You and Captain look at the map. Do you want that one, nameless sandbar all to yourselves? Let’s go.
• Access: We have the time (and the vessel) to sail to the remote cays, leaving the “tourist zone” (and our competitors) miles behind.

Don’t let a generic “Top 10” list (written by a broker) trick you into visiting a crowded beach. The “best island in San Blas” is the one you have all to yourself.

Let’s go find it together.

Book Your Private Island Expedition Now